Investing in Gold Bonds & ETFs

Investing in gold bonds and ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) offers a safer and more convenient alternative to holding physical gold for investment purpose. Here’s a breakdown of their benefits and considerations:

What are ETF?

An ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) is a type of investment fund that tracks the price of gold and trades on stock exchanges, just like shares. Instead of owning physical gold, investors hold units of the ETF, which represent a specific quantity of gold, typically 1 gram.

Gold ETFs provide liquidity and ease of trading, allowing investors to buy or sell units on the exchange throughout the trading day.

How does ETF work?

Gold ETFs function by allowing investors to purchase units of the fund on the stock exchange, similar to buying shares of a company. Gold ETFs are backed by physical gold held by a custodian, ensuring that each unit has intrinsic value linked to actual gold reserves. This makes them a convenient option for investors who want to deal in gold without dealing with the challenges of storing or securing physical gold.

When investors buy a unit of a Gold ETF, they are indirectly investing in gold, as the ETF is backed by physical gold stored in vaults. These funds can be bought or sold during market hours, offering flexibility and liquidity. The price of the ETF mirrors the current gold price. Investors here generally benefit from price appreciation.

Advantages of Investing in Gold ETFs

Some of the advantages of investing in gold ETFs include:

• No Storage Hassles: Since the gold is held by the fund, investors entirely avoid the costs and risks associated with storing it.
• High Liquidity: Gold ETFs can be easily traded on stock exchanges. This allows for quick buying and selling at market prices.
• Low Investment Costs: Compared to buying physical gold, ETFs typically involve lower costs when it comes to making charges, storage, and security.
• Transparency: The price of Gold ETFs is directly linked to the live market price of gold. This makes it transparent and an easy investment.

Disadvantages of Gold ETFs

Some of the disadvantages of investing in gold ETFs include:

• No Tangible Asset: Unlike physical gold, investors don’t possess gold. They only own units representing its value.
• Market Risk: Gold ETFs are subject to market risks and can fluctuate with overall market conditions, even if the underlying asset is stable.
• Management Fees: Although lower than physical gold’s storage costs, ETFs have management fees that can reduce returns over time.
• Limited Accessibility: Investors need access to a demat and trading account to invest in Gold ETFs. Usually, this might not be convenient for all.

Key Differences between Gold ETFs and Physical Golds

Gold ETFs and physical gold differ in ownership and liquidity. While physical gold provides tangible assets, Gold ETFs offer digital ownership with higher liquidity and lower costs. Unlike sovereign gold bonds, which also offer digital ownership, ETFs allow more flexible trading without long lock-in periods. Listed below is a tabular representation of gold ETFs vs physical gold.

• Tangibility vs. Digital Ownership

  • Gold ETF – It represents digital ownership, where investors hold units of gold in electronic form without ever physically possessing it.
  • Physical Gold – One of the primary differences between gold ETFs vs physical gold is ownership. With physical gold, you own a tangible asset that you can hold, store, and pass down, which offers a sense of security.

• Investment Costs and Fees

  • Gold ETF – Gold ETFs come with management fees charged by the fund. However, the overall cost of investing in Gold ETFs is often lower than physical gold due to the absence of making charges and the ability to trade in smaller quantities.
  • Physical Gold – Physical gold involves additional expenses like making charges, storage fees, and insurance costs.

Liquidity and Market Accessibility

• Gold ETF – Gold ETFs are far more liquid and accessible compared to physical gold. ETFs can be bought and sold instantly during market hours through stock exchanges. This offers investors quick access to their funds.
• Physical Gold – Physical gold, however, is less liquid since it requires finding a buyer. Sales may involve price deductions for purity checks or making charges.

Tax Implications of Each Investment

• Gold ETF – Gold ETFs are treated as financial assets, with a lower long-term capital gains tax and no wealth tax. Additionally, Gold ETFs provide the benefit of indexation, which further reduces tax liabilities on long-term holdings.
• Physical Gold – In India, long-term capital gains tax (after three years) on physical gold is higher, and the transaction is subject to wealth tax.

Which Investment is Right for You: Physical Gold vs Gold ETFs?

Choosing one between gold ETFs vs physical gold entirely depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and personal preferences. Investors seeking emotional value or a tangible asset may lean toward physical gold, while those prioritising convenience, liquidity, and lower costs may find Gold ETFs more appealing. It is also important to evaluate your investment horizon, storage capability, and tax considerations before making a decision.

There are several factors that need to be considered before finalizing one among gold ETFs vs physical gold.

• Purpose of Investment: Are you investing for sentimental reasons (e.g., family heirloom) or purely for financial gains?
• Investment Horizon: Are you looking for long-term wealth preservation or short-term trading?
• Convenience: Do you prefer the ease of digital transactions with Gold ETFs or the tangible ownership of physical gold?
• Costs: Can you manage the storage and insurance costs of physical gold, or would you rather avoid those by paying ETF management fees?
• Liquidity Requirements: Do you need quick and easy access to your investment, which Gold ETFs provide, or are you fine with the slower sale process of physical gold?
• Market Knowledge: Are you comfortable trading on the stock exchange (for ETFs) or more confident buying and holding physical assets?

Ideal Scenarios for Physical Gold vs. Gold ETFs

Some of the most ideal scenarios that makes it easier to choose among gold ETFs vs physical gold include:

• Physical Gold
  • Long-term holding for cultural or emotional reasons.
  • Desire for a tangible asset.
  • Willingness to bear storage and insurance costs.
• Gold ETFs
  • Seeking liquidity and ease of trading.
  • Prefer low storage costs and no making charges.
  • Interested in short-term or flexible investments.
  • Concerned about tax efficiency and market transparency.

Gold Bonds

Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) are government securities denominated in grams of gold, acting as a substitute for physical gold. They offer a way to invest in gold without the hassle of storage and security risks associated with physical gold. SGBs are issued by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on behalf of the Government of India.

Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) are not allowed to invest in Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs). However, if a resident investor becomes an NRI after purchasing SGBs, they can continue to hold the bonds until maturity or early redemption.

Key features of Sovereign Gold Bonds:

• Denomination: SGBs are priced in grams of gold, with a basic unit of 1 gram.
• Investment: Investors purchase SGBs when the scheme is open, and the bonds are redeemed on maturity.
• Interest: SGBs offer a fixed interest rate, currently 2.5% per annum, paid semi-annually.
• Maturity: The bonds have a tenure of 8 years, with an exit option available after the fifth year and sixth month.
• Redemption: At maturity, investors receive the initial investment value adjusted for the market price of gold at the time of redemption.
• Tax on Capital Gains: Yes, capital gains tax applies to Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) if they are sold in the secondary market before maturity. However, if the SGBs are held until maturity (eight years) and redeemed through the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the capital gains are completely exempt from taxation.
• Trading: SGBs can be traded on stock exchanges in demat form.
• Investment Limits: There are limits on the maximum amount of gold that can be subscribed in SGBs per investor (individual and HUF) and for other entities like trusts.
• Advantages:
  • Safety: Gold bonds are issued by the government, reducing the risk of theft or loss associated with physical gold.
  • Interest Earnings: Many gold bonds pay interest over their tenure, providing an additional return on investment.
  • No Storage Costs: Unlike physical gold, there are no costs for storage or insurance.
  • Tax Benefits: In some countries, capital gains from gold bonds may be tax-exempt if held until maturity.
• Disadvantages:
  • Liquidity: While they can be traded, liquidity may be less than ETFs.
  • Market Risk: Prices can fluctuate based on market conditions.

FAQs